Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, we are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

1. Mere title of a person within an organization such as Managing Director/ CEO does not automatically make the person criminally liable for offence committed by Company under Drug Laws. In order to make a person holding a managerial position in the company criminally liable, the complaint should have specific averments against such person which indicates that the person was in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the company so far as it relates to the manufacture of the drug: High Court of Jammu and Kashmir
Source: bit.ly/4cYU4Rl

2. The Government of India is reportedly considering whether to stop marketing of look-alike and sound-alike drug brands in public interest. Under the current proposal, the brand names which were approved first by the drug regulator will be permitted to be marketed, and look-alike or sound-alike drug brands will be prohibited from being marketed.
Source: bit.ly/3SvoDFN

3. The Indian Government is reportedly considering whether to exempt Medical Devices which have been approved and sold in the European Union for two years from requirement of conducting clinical investigation in India prior to marketing authorization.
Source: bit.ly/4d3sJgC

4. The Delhi High Court has ordered an Ayurvedic medicine manufacturer to delete from all websites on the internet and social-media platforms claims which were beyond the scope of license and implied that the medicine it marketed could treat COVID-19.
Source: bit.ly/3WFxEyG

5. A prominent US based health savings account administrator has reported that it has suffered a data breach which has led to the loss of sensitive employee and customer information.
Source: bit.ly/4dkt525

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

1. India’s central food regulator has approved a proposed Amendment to the Food Safety Standards (Labelling and Display) Regulations, 2020, to now indicate the per-serving Recommended Dietary Allowances, sugar, salt and sodium content in larger font.
Source: bit.ly/4bB3IYw

2. Association of Indian Medical Device Industry has requested the Ministry of Finance to increase the import tariffs on Medical Devices, correct the inverted duty structure, and to introduce new cap on trade margin in a bid to encourage the development of indigenous industry and competition.
Source: bit.ly/3VWQSOP

3. The Ministry of Consumer Affairs has set up a meeting with Automobile manufacturers operating India, and various Automobile manufactures Associations in an effort to onboard these companies on the Right-to-Repair portal maintained by the Ministry, and which has already onboarded several consumer electronics companies.
Source: bit.ly/4coI0bD

4. The Supreme Court, in the course of ongoing proceedings, has granted the Central Government an additional period of 8 weeks to frame a National Policy on Distribution of Menstrual Products (to adolescent children).
Source: bit.ly/4cTgvGV

5. The European Commission’s Medical Device Coordination Group has issued a new guidance amending the Guidance on “Classification Rules for in vitro Diagnostic Medical Devices under Regulation (EU) 2017/746” regarding the classification of In-Vitro Medical Devices at the pre-market introduction stage. The new amendment provides differential Conformity Assessment for the Devices based on their classification; The guidance has also provided an annex differentiating an In-Vitro Medical Device and a Companion Diagnosis.
Source: bit.ly/3Y2Ffbs

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, we are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Supreme Court clarifies when a patient’s negligence may be reduced due to pre-existing conditions
India’s Supreme Court has laid down the situations in which a patient’s claim for compensation due to medical negligence may be reduced on the grounds of pre-existing conditions. These are: First, when a latent condition of the patient has been unearthed; Second, when the negligence on the part of the wrongdoer re-activates a patient’s pre-existing condition that had subsided due to treatment; Third, wrongdoer’s actions aggravate known, pre-existing conditions, that have not yet received medical attention; and Fourth, when the wrongdoer’s actions accelerate an inevitable disability or loss of life due to a condition possessed by the patient even when the eventuality would have occurred with time, in the absence of the wrongdoer’s actions. This rule is commonly referred to as the ‘egg-shell skull’ rule.
Revised penalty will apply, even if the offence took place before the penalty is revised: Supreme Court
India’s Supreme Court has held that a repealed provision will cease to operate from the date of repeal and the substituted provision will commence to operate from the date of its substitution. The Court was dealing with a matter involving the determination of penalty for loss of liquor in transit. The unamended rule, which existed at the time when the breach happened, provided for a penalty of four times the duty payable on liquor.  The amended rule provided for a penalty equal to the duty payable on liquor. Since no additional guidance for the application of the amended rule was prescribed, the Supreme Court held that the amended penalty provision would apply.
Proceedings related to alcohol content in drugs under excise laws and drug laws can run concurrently: High Court
India’s Gujarat High Court has clarified that action under the Drugs & Cosmetics Act does not exempt an individual from prosecution if a case is made out under the Gujarat Prohibition Act, 1949. In this case, a pharmaceutical manufacturer had allegedly violated the State’s prohibition law by selling intoxicating substances as ayurvedic medicine and, therefore, was facing action against the excise laws as well as drug laws.
Limits on the import of Isopropyl alcohol relaxed
India’s Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) has notified the discontinuation of safeguard measures on the import of isopropyl alcohol (IPA) through a trade notice. Earlier, country-wise quantitative restrictions (QR) were imposed on the import of IPA into India.
Used imported medical devices with a minimum shelf life of 5 years are not waste: Tribunal
India’s Hyderabad Bench of Customs, Excise, and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) has held that used medical devices with a minimum residual life of 5 years or more are not e-waste or hazardous waste. In this matter, a hospital had imported used medical equipment for internal use but the Customs had seized the capital equipment on grounds that the used medical equipment qualified as hazardous waste under the Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016
Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Delay condonation should be evaluated based on reasons provided and not merits of case: Supreme Court
In a recent decision, the Supreme Court held that in condoning delay for a filing for which limitation period has been stipulated under the Limitation Act, 1963, a Court should not base its decision on whether such delay has been condoned in a similar matter, evaluating delay on merits of the fact situation, but rather each delay should be evaluated on the grounds pleaded in the application for its condonation.
Source: bit.ly/49MllnH

Central Government to take strict action against non-compliance with quality maintenance in manufacture of fire-resistant fabrics raw material
The Indian Central Government is intending to take stringent action against violators of the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) Quality Control Order for raw material used to manufacture fire-resistant fabric used in upholstery used in commercial spaces such as cinema halls, conference halls etc. Pursuant to issue of this Quality Control Order, only those raw material that have been certified by the BIS may be used in manufacture of commercial space upholstery. However, this Quality Control Order does not apply to upholstery used in households or those manufactured for export.
Source: bit.ly/4cKT4R3

Indian Government partners with Quality Council of India to improve services at Central Government run hospitals
India’s Central Ministry of Health and Family Welfare has entered into a Memorandum of Understanding with the Quality Council of India, to help improve quality standards for healthcare delivery at government run hospitals and help the hospitals get accredited by the National Accreditation Body for Hospitals/ Laboratories.
Source: bit.ly/3Ub0ful

Prices of imported Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient see sharp decline due to action against cartelized manufacturers
Despite an increase in demand in the Indian domestic pharmaceutical manufacturing sector for Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients (APIs), indicated by a 39% increase in year-on-year imports, the price of APIs being imported from China and other countries has reduced significantly to pre-COVID levels. This reduction is suspected to be caused by breaking-down of manufacturing cartels. This reduction in prices of API signifies an increase in profit margins for Indian firms which have traditionally been depended on Chinese imports.
Source: bit.ly/43Qlo0d

ECHR holds that inaction against climate change may be considered violation of human rights
The European Court of Human Rights has issued an award in favour of several Switzerland based petitioners who brought claims against their Government. The Court held that the European Convention on Human Rights envisages citizens right to be protected by their government against adverse effects of climate change. The petitioners had claimed that the inaction of the Swiss government and insufficient mitigation measures had caused a violation of the petitioners’ human rights, since such inaction by the government has increased their likelihood of dying of heat stroke.
Source: bit.ly/3JbMLZ6

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Environmental Compensation Guidelines for Plastic Waste Published
India’s Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) has issued guidelines for the assessment of Environmental Compensation (EC) for violation of The Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016. The Producers, Importers, Brand Owners and Manufacturers of plastic packaging will have to pay environmental compensation (EC) for non-compliance with the marking or labelling requirements, non-registration on the Plastic Packaging Waste EPR portal, shortfall in EPR targets, non-filing of annual returns etc. EC would also be levied on the generators of waste for non-segregation of plastic packaging waste at source and littering. The environmental compensation will be higher (15 – 20%) than the EPR credit charges prevailing in the market to ensure that it acts as a deterrent. The guidelines also specify the minimum and maximum amount of environmental compensation to be levied for violations of specific provisions of the Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016.
Source: bit.ly/3U6zhUJ

Importer of cosmetics inadvertently receives import registration for cosmetic product without applying for it
India’s Central Regulatory Body for Cosmetics, The Central Drugs Standard Control Organization (CDSCO), recently cancelled the import registration certificate of an importer of cosmetics after it realized that it had inadvertently granted registration certificate even though the importer had not applied for it. CDSCO has attributed the mistake to some technical issues.
Source: bit.ly/3vNc0xQ

Hair transplantation by doctor with M.B.B.S. degree only does not automatically result in negligence, if standard of care not compromised by doctor: National Consumer Commission
India’s National Consumer Dispute Redressal Commission (NCDRC) in Hyderabad refuse to fasten liability for medical negligence on a Doctor with M.B.B.S, who had performed a hair transplant surgery. The NCDRC observed that the M.B.B.S. course syllabus includes study of the dermis, and that a doctor with a M.B.B.S. degree has the qualifications and expertise to undertake minor surgeries of dermis such as hair transplantation.
Source: bit.ly/3PWQBZN

Indian hospitals have started using Artificial Intelligence extensively: Report
India’s major hospital chains have reportedly started using artificial intelligence (AI) for prediction, prevention, diagnosis, and personalized management. These hospital chains are also commercializing their AI solution by licensing it with smaller hospitals.
Source: bit.ly/43Ua6rF

French Government decides to impose fines on patients if they miss appointment with doctors
The French government has decided to impose a fine of five euro ($5.50) on patients who miss doctor appointments or cancel them with less than twenty-four hours’ notice. The Government homes that this initiative would free up missed appointments for other patients. It is reported that over 27 million doctor consultations go waste in France due to patient absences.
Source: bit.ly/49p7Iug

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Body massagers cannot be ‘sex toys’ just because they can have alternative use: High Court

In a recent ruling, the Bombay High Court has held that body massagers cannot be treated as ‘sex toys’ merely because they can be used for alternative purposes. While coming to this conclusion, the Court observed that it would be incorrect to classify massagers
as items of objectionable description or as obscene figures in the absence of any substantial justification.

Source: bit.ly/3Vvxp9k

Homeopathy practitioners cannot present themselves as gynaecologist; amounts to medical negligence and deficiency in service: State Consumer Commission

The State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Lucknow (SCDRC) has taken the view that cross-practicing of medicine by doctors trained in branches other than allopathy constitutes medical negligence and a deficiency in service. SCDRC imposed a compensation of Rs. 30 Lakhs on a city-based private nursing home and a homeopathy practitioner for medical negligence. The practitioner misrepresented herself as a gynaecologist, and prescribed allopathic medicines. The SCDRC held both the practitioner and the nursing home liable for their negligence and deficiency in service.

Source: bit.ly/3xavblG

A leading ayurvedic Indian FMCG company has tendered an unconditional apology for its misleading advertisement to Supreme Court

Following a contempt notice on misleading advertisements and the issue of summons, the co-founders of a major ayurvedic FMCG company have tendered an unconditional apology for the company’s misleading advertising practices. The Supreme Court had directed that the co-founders of the company appear personally before the Court on the date of the next hearing. 

Source: bit.ly/43vV5wj 

Government proposes ban on 23 dangerous dog breeds in India

The Indian Government proposed a ban on 23 dog breeds in the country that are deemed “dangerous for human life” in an effort to address the growing number of dog attack cases. Additionally, the government has urged state governments to desist from granting licenses or permits for the sale and breeding of these dog breeds. 

Source: bit.ly/43xEjgi 

Draft Resolution introduced by the UN General Assembly on Artificial Intelligence

The UN General Assembly adopted its first resolution on artificial intelligence (AI) to ensure the technology benefits all nations while respecting human rights and ensuring safety.
Co-sponsored by 123 states, the resolution was adopted by consensus without a vote. Recently, the European Parliament has also taken steps to adopt the Artificial Intelligence Act, considered the world’s first comprehensive legal framework for AI.

Source: bit.ly/490W88s

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Periodic Safety Update Reports for Medical Devices to be filed only through online portal of CDSCO
The Central Medical Devices Regulator of India (Central Drugs Standards Control Organization) has issued a circular, stating that starting on 1st April 2024 it will require and restrict all manufacturers of Medical Devices/ In-vitro Devices to make submission of Periodic Safety Update Reports, only on the online portal and that offline mode of submission of application will not be accepted going forward.
Source: bit.ly/3TEO74B

Absence of Regulation of Second-Hand Medical Devices being Imported into India flagged by Parliamentary Panel
The Department-related Parliamentary Standing Committee on Chemicals and Fertilisers, in a recent report, has highlighted that currently India’s Central Medical Device Regulations (Medical Devices Rules, 2017) do not regulate second-hand medical devices. The Committee has recommended framing policy to ensure its quality and safety, as well as introducing possible restrictions on import of second-hand or refurbished Medical Devices into India.
Source: bit.ly/3VsdCaQ

Supreme Court Orders Director of Company as well as Endorser of offending Advertisement to be present for Contempt Proceedings relating to misleading advertisements
As part of the ongoing action being taken against a major Indian Ayurvedic Medicine manufacturer for publication of misleading advertisements regarding its products in contravention of an undertaking provided to the Court, the Supreme Court, in pursuance of determining whether to pursue contempt proceedings against the manufacturer, has issued an order requiring the physical presence of the Director of the entity as well as a prominent Ayurvedic Yoga practitioner who had given his endorsement to the claims made in the offending advertisements of the Company.
Source: bit.ly/3vu45VQ

Delhi High Court orders suspension of accounts accused of impersonation of prominent investment group despite objection that no evidence of involvement is provided.
In pursuance of ongoing action against certain anonymous persons impersonating a prominent Investment group and misleading the general public, the Delhi High Court has issued a further order to messaging platform WhatsApp to take action to remove/ block access to certain accounts/ messaging groups, despite objection from the platform that the account/ messaging groups have been prove to neither violate T&Cs of WhatsApp, nor having carried out any illegal activity.
Source: bit.ly/3vkn7hu

EU Parliamentary Committee votes to present amendment to increase exclusivity period for orphan drugs and introduce extended regulatory data-protection period.
The European Parliamentary Committee on Environment, Public Health and Food Safety has voted in favour of introducing several amendments to the current EU Pharmaceutical Directive, including a controversial proposal to increase the exclusivity period for Orphan Drugs from 10 to 11 years, as well as an extended regulatory data-protection period of 9 years; both decisions that industry experts believe may have adverse consequences for competition in the EU Pharmaceutical Market.
Source: bit.ly/3Vr9zeK

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

State Consumer Commissions continue to dilute intermediary safe-harbour protection for e-commerce marketplace
A State Consumer Commission in India has held a major e-commerce marketplace company liable for delivery of incorrect goods to customers, on the grounds that since it offered a ‘fulfilling’ service on behalf of the seller, it was not merely an intermediary but also an agent of the seller. The marketplace was made to pay punitive damages, in addition to mental harassment, on grounds that it may have unscrupulously exploited an unknown uncounted number of consumers.
Source: bit.ly/49VuNW0

Kochi and Thiruvananthapuram proposed to be added to the list of airports from where drugs may be imported
India’s Ministry of Health and Family Welfare has issued a draft notification that will add Kochi and Thiruvananthapuram to the list of airports from which pharmaceutical drugs may be imported into India. The Drugs Rules, 1945 specify that pharmaceutical drugs may be imported into India from a specified number of airports only. The clearance of drugs requires the approval of the Additional Drugs Controller (ADC) Customs, who is generally posted at the customs wing of the airport.
Source: bit.ly/49zbUZ8

Dengue Vaccine Clinical Trials to start soon in India
A major Japanese drug maker has reportedly received clearance from India’s vaccine regulator, Central Drugs Standards Control Organization, to start clinical trials of the dengue vaccine. The vaccine will be contract manufactured by a major biotech company in India.
Source: bit.ly/49OyQ7b

Many medical device companies settled allegations of kickbacks given to doctors in 2023: US Department of Justice
The US Department of Justice (DoJ) has issued a press release that it has recorded the highest number of settlements and judgements in its history. Some of major settlements involved allegations of unlawful kickbacks medical device companies to doctors, in form of above-fair market value supervision fees or remuneration for medical directorships and improper donation of capital equipment.
Source: bit.ly/49X0H4H

Fair-use defense against copyright infringement by AI companies will be tested in new trial by media companies against Open AI
In a new set of lawsuits in the US, media companies are not alleging copyright infringement by AI companies to train the algorithm, but instead alleging that before training, the AI companies removed information from the training material which established that the material was copyrighted, such as the name of the author the news. The Digital Millennium Copyright Act or DMCA, law in the US reportedly prohibits the removal of information that can help copyright holders detect infringement, including article titles, author names, and copyright dates.
Source: bit.ly/3Ih1MbA

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Major Indian Ayurvedic Medicine Manufacturer to be tried for Contempt of Court for publishing misleading drug advertisements
India’s Supreme Court is reportedly set to issue a Contempt Notice to a major Ayurvedic medicines manufacturer in India after it found out that the manufacturer had published a misleading advertisement claiming permanent relief for certain chronic conditions such as Diabetes and Liver Cirrhosis. In November 2023, the manufacturer had given an undertaking to the Supreme Court that it will not publish misleading advertisements or disparage allopathy. The Supreme Court has also questioned the Indian government for its inaction over publication of misleading advertisements by the manufacturer despite existence of a law which makes publication of misleading advertisement punishable with imprisonment.
Source: bit.ly/42U33yI

Doctors will have to obtain registration with State Medical Council of every State where they practice: Delhi HC
The High Court of Delhi has upheld the legality of a notice issued by Delhi Medical Council which made it mandatory for Doctors to register with the Council if they wanted to practice in the State of Delhi. The Doctors argued that it was an onerous requirement which would require them to register in every State they practice in. However, the Court held that the intent of the law is to require Doctors to register in every State that they practice in, and that Doctors have the option to register with multiple State Medical Councils in India.
Source: bit.ly/3TgHANw

Cosmetic Importers asked to provide sales details in a bid to curb import of counterfeit cosmetics
In an effort to curb the import of counterfeit cosmetic products, India’s Central Cosmetics Regulator, Drugs Controller General of India, has directed importers of cosmetics who import cosmetics already registered by authorized importers, to furnish annual sales details such as number of consignments, imported quantity, total cost of imported cosmetics of each consignment, along with warehouse details.
Source: bit.ly/42T2IMR

Central Government has to fix ceiling prices of medical treatment within 2 months: Supreme Court
The Supreme Court has directed the Central Government publish ceiling prices for medical treatments offered by Hospitals all over the country within 2 months. If the Central Government fails to do so, the Supreme Court has said that it will direct Central Government to fix medical treatment costs stipulated under Central Government Health Scheme as ceiling price of medical treatment offered by Hospitals for the whole country.
Source: bit.ly/3wsyHHs

India Seeks to delay implementation of EU Carbon Emissions Limits
India is set to conduct negotiation with the European Union regarding the implementation of the Carbon Control Regime, seeking a complete elimination of the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, failing which India will seek an extension of timelines for reduction of emissions. It is expected that in order to comply with requirements under EU Carbon Control Regime, Indian exporters will have to make significant capital investment will increase cost of production.
Source: bit.ly/42S7DxH

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

India’s new criminal law regime to take effect from July 1, 2024
The three criminal laws, namely, Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita, Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam that will replace the erstwhile the Indian Penal Code, 1860; Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898; and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, respectively, will take effect from July 1, 2024. However, Section 106 (2) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 which provides for punishment of “0-10 years” in “hit and run” cases, has been put on hold.
Source: bit.ly/3P13RMz
Source: bit.ly/3TbqvUU
Source: bit.ly/3wxhexO

Cosmetic Importers in India who are not directly authorized by foreign manufacturer must submit annual statement of import to Cosmetics Regulator
The Central Drugs Standard Control Organisation (CDSCO) has issued a circular reminding cosmetics importers who have obtained Import Registration Number (IRN) in Form Cos-4A, that is on the strength of prior import registration issued to an importer authorized by the foreign manufacturer, to provide annual statement of cosmetics imported in India from date of grant of IRN. The importers have also been advised to furnish details such as number of consignments, imported quantity, total cost of imported cosmetics of each consignment, along with warehouse details.
Source: bit.ly/49L6bzl

Timeline for obtaining Standard Mark for sanitary napkins, baby diapers and reusable sanitary pad/napkins extended to 1st October.
India’s Ministry of Textiles has extended the date of enforcement of Medical Textiles (Quality Control) Order, 2023 from 1st April to 1st October 2024. The said order requires that Foreign as well as Indian manufacturers of sanitary napkins, baby diapers and reusable sanitary pad/napkins to obtain a standard mark and label the products with a standard mark before the products are sold in India.
Source: bit.ly/3IjAWiV

Inspection of food manufacturers/processors in non-mandatory classes should be completed within 15 days: India’s food regulator
The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) has issued an advisory to State Food Licensing Authorities for processing licensing applications of manufacturers of food categories which do not warrant mandatory inspection such as prepared foods, Indian sweets, egg and egg products, foodstuff intended for nutritional supplements. The FSSAI has advised that such applications should ideally be cleared without inspection, but if for some reason an inspection is deemed to be warranted, then such inspection should be concluded within 15 days from date when the application is marked for inspection.
Source: bit.ly/3wwHNTN

Germany legalises private cultivation and recreational use of cannabis
Germany has passed a law legalizing cultivation of up to three cannabis plants and for owning 25 grams of cannabis for private consumption. The law also permits establishment of cannabis clubs to facilitate consumption with a cap of 500 members. Germany has become ninth country to legalise private recreational use of cannabis.
Source: bit.ly/3OSK6a3