Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Corporate hospitals may soon have to comply with advertisement norms applicable to doctors

India’s National Medical Commission (NMC), which regulates the conduct of medical practitioners (doctors), has endorsed the position that all hospitals should comply with the same standards of ethics as are applicable to doctors under the NMC Registered Medical Practitioner (Professional Conduct) Regulations, 2023. The operation of 2023 Regulations is currently under suspension.
Source: bit.ly/3vpJ7aV

High Court imposes damages of 244 crores in Standard Essential Patents case

India’s Delhi High Court has reportedly imposed damages amounting to INR 244 Crores on an Indian smartphone manufacturer. The Court found smartphone manufacturer guilty of infringing seven patents on 2G, EDGE, and 3G technology granted to a global telecom company. The order is expected to be out soon.
Source: bit.ly/3TxOXyI

Drug Manufacturers will have to upload all product details on Government portal soon

The Drugs Consultative Committee (DCC), a committee comprising State-level Drug Regulators, has recommended that the Central Drugs Regulator, Central Drugs Standard Control Organization (CDSCO), should set a deadline for manufacturers of drugs to upload list of drugs manufactured on an online portal called SUGAM.
Source: bit.ly/3TxP0uo

Ban on trade of ferocious dog breeds has been stayed in various States in India

India’s Kerala High Court, Karnataka High Court and Kolkata High Court has stayed a controversial circular of the Central Government which prohibited import, trading and selling of 23 breeds of dogs identified as ferocious in the circular. The circular also mandated sterilization of dogs from further breeding as pets. The circular has been challenged on the ground that it is unscientific, not based on evidence and has been issued without consultation with relevant stakeholders.
Source: bit.ly/3TVZcyi

European Medicines Agency urges sponsors of clinical trials to register on new portal before January 2025 deadline

The European Medicines Agency (EMA) has strongly advised sponsors of clinical trials that have been approved before 31 January 2023 to submit application to move the clinical trials to the new Clinical Trials Information System (CTIS) as soon as possible, considering it will take EMA up to three months to review and authorize the application. As of now, only 20% of clinical trials have been moved to the new platform.
Source: bit.ly/3TZRzHl

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Star-rating for energy efficiency on white goods to be under stricter government regulation

Indian Government may reportedly introduce rules for non-branded products to validate star rating for energy efficiency on white goods. White goods refer to household appliances of daily use such as air conditioners, refrigerators, television sets, etc. The National Test House (NTH), along with Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE), will conduct testing to help improve the quality of products and put a check on substandard products with a view to save energy.
Source: bit.ly/3TAWopa  

US FDA to train Indian drug regulators on cGMP inspection

The US FDA has invited drug regulators of the State of Gujarat, Telangana, Goa, and Karnataka to act as observers during checks and inspections of drug facilities in India, so that they develop a greater understanding of the US FDA inspection protocol.
Source: bit.ly/43FfvD9

GST officials should refrain from doing fishing inquiries: Government

The Directorate General of GST Intelligence (DGGI) has reportedly issued a new guideline for GST officials stating that they should refrain from “fishing inquiries” to check evasion of goods and service tax (GST). The Guidelines state that tax officers should clearly state the nature of the investigation in formal letters to designated company officials and avoid using ambiguous language in letters and summons. Terms like “GST enquiry,” “evasion of GST,” or “GST evasion,” among others, should not be used in a letter sent to an ordinary taxpayer.
Source: bit.ly/3IZO9Og  

Indian Courts will be slow to intervene in enforcement of foreign arbitral awards on grounds of bias: Supreme Court 

India’s Supreme Court has held that intervention in enforcement of a foreign arbitral award on the grounds of bias should be discouraged. Indian courts will be permitted to entertain a claim for arbitral bias in an enforcement proceeding only after the ground has been raised before the arbitral tribunal. In order to assess arbitral bias, the Courts will have to prioritize international standards above domestic ones, even while it permits the execution of a foreign arbitral award. 
Source: bit.ly/3J48bqR  

Chemicals used to decaffeinate coffee beans may be banned in US 

Consumer Health Groups have petitioned US Food and Drug Administration to ban methylene chloride, a chemical which is used as additive to decaffeinate coffee beans, because it has been proven to cause cancer in rodents.
Source: bit.ly/3vx2n6a

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Criminal prosecution for drug related offences can start only on the basis of a drug inspector’s complaint: Supreme Court
India’s Supreme Court has confirmed that only a drug inspector, and not the police, is authorized to file a First Information Report (FIR) or a complaint for offence related to drugs under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940.
Source: bit.ly/3PGkEVL

Drug prices may increase slightly due to increase in Wholesale Price Index
India’s drug price regulator, the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority of India, has communicated to the pharmaceutical industry that annual change in the Wholesale Price Index (WPI) in 2023 compared to 2022 was (+)0.00551%. Accordingly, manufacturers of drugs whose price are capped may increase their price by (+)0.00551% in the month of April without government approval.
Source: bit.ly/3xgzbRC

Drug labels may have to mention excipients which cause hypersensitivity soon
India’s top drug policy advisory body, the Drugs Advisory Board (DTAB), has directed India’s Central Drug Regulator, The Central Drugs Standards Control Organization, to prepare a list of excipients that cause hypersensitivity, with the intent that such excipients should be disclosed label of medicine. Other excipients will not have to be mentioned on the labels of medicine. Currently, the law does not require manufacturers to include to disclose information about excipients on the label of drugs.
Source: bit.ly/43E3M7D
Source: bit.ly/3vv1j2N

India low on Biopharma Innovation: Leading Industry Analyst
A leading industry analyst firm has written an open letter to Prime Minister of India that India seems to be ceding ground to its Asian peers in biopharma innovation and manufacturing. The firm has highlighted that India needs to encourage investment in biopharma manufacturing capacity, increase public health expenditure, and extend insurance coverage for the novel drugs, in order to promote innovation in biopharma space.
Source: bit.ly/3PHcD2N

High time to implement essential diagnostic guidelines to standardize diagnostic practices: Expert
Healthcare industry expert in India has emphasized the urgent need for the implementation of national essential diagnostic guidelines to standardize practices, improve patient care, streamline diagnostic processes, guide clinical decision-making, optimize resource utilization, and reduce healthcare disparities across India. In 2019, the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) had issued the National Essential Diagnostic List (NEDL) to ensure consistency and quality in diagnostic procedures.
Source: bit.ly/3vyESd5

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Body massagers cannot be ‘sex toys’ just because they can have alternative use: High Court

In a recent ruling, the Bombay High Court has held that body massagers cannot be treated as ‘sex toys’ merely because they can be used for alternative purposes. While coming to this conclusion, the Court observed that it would be incorrect to classify massagers
as items of objectionable description or as obscene figures in the absence of any substantial justification.

Source: bit.ly/3Vvxp9k

Homeopathy practitioners cannot present themselves as gynaecologist; amounts to medical negligence and deficiency in service: State Consumer Commission

The State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Lucknow (SCDRC) has taken the view that cross-practicing of medicine by doctors trained in branches other than allopathy constitutes medical negligence and a deficiency in service. SCDRC imposed a compensation of Rs. 30 Lakhs on a city-based private nursing home and a homeopathy practitioner for medical negligence. The practitioner misrepresented herself as a gynaecologist, and prescribed allopathic medicines. The SCDRC held both the practitioner and the nursing home liable for their negligence and deficiency in service.

Source: bit.ly/3xavblG

A leading ayurvedic Indian FMCG company has tendered an unconditional apology for its misleading advertisement to Supreme Court

Following a contempt notice on misleading advertisements and the issue of summons, the co-founders of a major ayurvedic FMCG company have tendered an unconditional apology for the company’s misleading advertising practices. The Supreme Court had directed that the co-founders of the company appear personally before the Court on the date of the next hearing. 

Source: bit.ly/43vV5wj 

Government proposes ban on 23 dangerous dog breeds in India

The Indian Government proposed a ban on 23 dog breeds in the country that are deemed “dangerous for human life” in an effort to address the growing number of dog attack cases. Additionally, the government has urged state governments to desist from granting licenses or permits for the sale and breeding of these dog breeds. 

Source: bit.ly/43xEjgi 

Draft Resolution introduced by the UN General Assembly on Artificial Intelligence

The UN General Assembly adopted its first resolution on artificial intelligence (AI) to ensure the technology benefits all nations while respecting human rights and ensuring safety.
Co-sponsored by 123 states, the resolution was adopted by consensus without a vote. Recently, the European Parliament has also taken steps to adopt the Artificial Intelligence Act, considered the world’s first comprehensive legal framework for AI.

Source: bit.ly/490W88s

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Indian government may reconsider its decision of prohibiting manufacture of drugs and nutraceuticals, health supplements in same facility
The Indian government is reportedly reconsidering its decision to act against pharmaceutical companies who are manufacturing nutraceuticals, health supplements and drugs in the same facility, due to objections raised by small scale manufacturers. The previous Good Manufacturing Practices (Schedule M) for drugs gave some concession to manufacturers of drugs to manufacture nutraceuticals and health supplements in the same facility. However, no such concession exists under revised Good Manufacturing Practices (Schedule M) published in December 2023.
Source: bit.ly/3x59lQo

Exporters of Indian farm produce are facing phytosanitary challenges
Indian agricultural exports, including fruits and vegetables, are reportedly finding it difficult to enter regions like Europe, Australia, and the US due to tough phytosanitary requirements and thresholds such as high pesticide content. In response, India’s Commerce Ministry is reportedly creating a data set on export consignments of agricultural exports that were refused by European countries and other nations on grounds of phytosanitary non-compliances, resulting in significant trade hurdles regardless of duty relaxations. A phytosanitary certificate is required for the export of agricultural products to ensure that the produce is pest-free, disease-free, and meets other health requirements such as traceability at the farm level.
Source: bit.ly/4ctvxnB

Indian government has established Fact Check Units to check spread of fake news
The Indian Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology has appointed the Press Information Bureau of the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting as Fact Check Unit to address fake and misleading news against Central Government. The fact check unit of the central government is expected to vet all the online content related to the business of the central government. Any content identified as fake by the unit will be taken down from the internet.
Source: bit.ly/3Px3Yj8

The Centre gives more time to states to establish Allied Healthcare Councils
India’s Ministry of Health and Family Welfare has extended the timeline for states to establish state allied and healthcare councils by six months. State Governments have to setup State Councils for Allied Healthcare by November 2024. The National Commission for Allied and Healthcare Professions Act 2021, which regulates quality of allied and other healthcare professionals in India, will be operationalized once the State Councils have been established.
Sourve : bit.ly/3PxeZ4d

Integrated Veterinary Health Certificates (VHC) mandatory after 30th June,2024 for import of milk and milk products into India
The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) has extended the deadline for implementing its decision to require imported food consignment of milk and milk products to be supported by an integrated veterinary health certificate. The requirement will take effect on July 1, 2024. From that date, only those milk and milk products that are supported by integrated veterinary health certificates will be allowed importation into India. The Integrated Veterinary Health Certificate must demonstrate that imported milk and milk products meet both the FSSAI’s food safety standards and the Department of Animal Husbandry and Dairying’s (DAHD) sanitary criteria.
Source: bit.ly/3TIh53F

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Airlines have to obtain single caterer license and provide invoice containing description of license number for chargeable in-flight meals
India’s food regulator, The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI), has issued an advisory to flight operators directing them to ensure that they have appropriate license for providing in-flight food. The regulator has also directed flight operators to ensure that appropriate invoice with license number is issued for sale of food, and that both ready-to-serve and pre-packaged food carries appropriate labelling declaration.
Source: bit.ly/48NrSxN

In medical negligence matters, exoneration by medical council will not automatically mean exoneration before consumer forum, especially if contradictory medical evidence has been furnished: Supreme Court
India’s Supreme Court has held that a consumer commission which is deciding a complaint of medical negligence against a medical practitioner, should not solely rely on favourable report from State Medical Council especially if the complainant has submitted contradictory expert testimony from another medical practitioner.
Source: bit.ly/3Isb30J

Import of medicines to get boost from India’s free-trade agreement with four countries of European Free Trade Association (EFTA)
Four European Free Trade Association states, namely, Iceland, Liechtenstein, Norway and Switzerland, have signed a Trade and Economic Partnership Agreement with India for facilitating trade and investment flows. While India has secured soft investment commitments under the Agreement, EFTA states have been given concession on import duty on pharmaceutical products exported to India and have been promised simplified customs procedure.
Source: bit.ly/3TuP8w9

Limits for automatic exemption in combination cases before CCI increased
The Indian government has increased the asset and turnover thresholds for automatic exemption under India’s anti-trust regulations. For claiming the exemptions from prior approval requirement, the value of assets being acquired should be Rs. 450 crores as opposed earlier threshold of Rs. 350 crores. Similarly, the turnover should be Rs. 1250 crores as opposed earlier threshold of Rs 1000 crores.
Source: bit.ly/3VaYle6

Electrical appliances for hair and skin care would require Indian Standard Marks for sale in India from 4th March 2025
The Department for Promotion and Industry and Internal Trade has published a Quality Control Order (QCO) which makes it mandatory for importers and manufacturers of skin and hair electrical appliances to obtain an Indian Standard Mark (IS mark) from Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) in order to be able to sell in India. BIS grants rights to use IS Mark after testing and inspection of products and manufacturing facilities, both in India and abroad, and charges a fee on the products sold.
Source: bit.ly/4c8wSzW

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

India takes baby steps in regulation of Artificial Intelligence, puts in place prior consent requirement before deployment of AI
India’s Ministry of Electronic & Information Technology has reportedly advised platforms and intermediaries which employ artificial intelligence (“AI”) models or generative AI software, algorithms to mandatorily obtain government approval before offering their services. Additionally, platforms or intermediaries using unreliable AI models or algorithms should label themselves as “under testing” and take explicit consent from users, making them aware of potential errors in the technology.
Source: bit.ly/430rwT8

Indian Government to hold discussions with private hospitals on capping of medical treatment rates
India’s Ministry of Health and Family Welfare is reportedly in discussion with major corporate hospitals on the possibility of capping of medical treatment rates. India’s Supreme Court last week had directed the Ministry to exercise its powers under Clinical Establishment Rules for prescribing ceiling prices of medical treatments, and threatened that if it did not do so, the Court will itself direct the Ministry to notify Central Government Health Scheme (CGHS) rates as ceiling prices for medical treatments across the country.
Source: bit.ly/3wGw6di

Eye drops in India may soon have to be sold in transparent bottles to detect contamination
India’s central drug regulator, the Drugs Controller General of India, has called a meeting with pharmaceutical manufacturer associations to propose the use of transparent bottles in packaging eye drops. It is expected that use of transparent bottles will help detect contamination and particulate matter, so that any damage to the eye due to contaminated or spurious eye drops may be avoided. Most eye drops are currently sold in opaque bottles.
Source: bit.ly/3UX4Lxv

Yogurt makers may lawfully claim that it can reduce the risk of type 2 diabetes: US FDA
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has reportedly allowed dairy-based yogurt makers to claim that Yogurt may reduce the risk of type 2 diabetes. However, the US FDA has recommended that the claim may be used carefully in yogurts that contain high levels of added sugar.
Source: bit.ly/3STFDF2

Legal validity of US Medicare drug price negotiation program upheld
A federal judge in Delaware in US has upheld the legal validity of U.S government’s condition that manufacturers of Top 10 drugs which are used in Medicare health insurance program will have to reduce prices or stop supplying to the program. This is the third positive court ruling in favour of US Government in the last few weeks on the subject of price negotiations.
Source: bit.ly/4bZbOM8

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

State Consumer Commissions continue to dilute intermediary safe-harbour protection for e-commerce marketplace
A State Consumer Commission in India has held a major e-commerce marketplace company liable for delivery of incorrect goods to customers, on the grounds that since it offered a ‘fulfilling’ service on behalf of the seller, it was not merely an intermediary but also an agent of the seller. The marketplace was made to pay punitive damages, in addition to mental harassment, on grounds that it may have unscrupulously exploited an unknown uncounted number of consumers.
Source: bit.ly/49VuNW0

Kochi and Thiruvananthapuram proposed to be added to the list of airports from where drugs may be imported
India’s Ministry of Health and Family Welfare has issued a draft notification that will add Kochi and Thiruvananthapuram to the list of airports from which pharmaceutical drugs may be imported into India. The Drugs Rules, 1945 specify that pharmaceutical drugs may be imported into India from a specified number of airports only. The clearance of drugs requires the approval of the Additional Drugs Controller (ADC) Customs, who is generally posted at the customs wing of the airport.
Source: bit.ly/49zbUZ8

Dengue Vaccine Clinical Trials to start soon in India
A major Japanese drug maker has reportedly received clearance from India’s vaccine regulator, Central Drugs Standards Control Organization, to start clinical trials of the dengue vaccine. The vaccine will be contract manufactured by a major biotech company in India.
Source: bit.ly/49OyQ7b

Many medical device companies settled allegations of kickbacks given to doctors in 2023: US Department of Justice
The US Department of Justice (DoJ) has issued a press release that it has recorded the highest number of settlements and judgements in its history. Some of major settlements involved allegations of unlawful kickbacks medical device companies to doctors, in form of above-fair market value supervision fees or remuneration for medical directorships and improper donation of capital equipment.
Source: bit.ly/49X0H4H

Fair-use defense against copyright infringement by AI companies will be tested in new trial by media companies against Open AI
In a new set of lawsuits in the US, media companies are not alleging copyright infringement by AI companies to train the algorithm, but instead alleging that before training, the AI companies removed information from the training material which established that the material was copyrighted, such as the name of the author the news. The Digital Millennium Copyright Act or DMCA, law in the US reportedly prohibits the removal of information that can help copyright holders detect infringement, including article titles, author names, and copyright dates.
Source: bit.ly/3Ih1MbA

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Major Indian Ayurvedic Medicine Manufacturer to be tried for Contempt of Court for publishing misleading drug advertisements
India’s Supreme Court is reportedly set to issue a Contempt Notice to a major Ayurvedic medicines manufacturer in India after it found out that the manufacturer had published a misleading advertisement claiming permanent relief for certain chronic conditions such as Diabetes and Liver Cirrhosis. In November 2023, the manufacturer had given an undertaking to the Supreme Court that it will not publish misleading advertisements or disparage allopathy. The Supreme Court has also questioned the Indian government for its inaction over publication of misleading advertisements by the manufacturer despite existence of a law which makes publication of misleading advertisement punishable with imprisonment.
Source: bit.ly/42U33yI

Doctors will have to obtain registration with State Medical Council of every State where they practice: Delhi HC
The High Court of Delhi has upheld the legality of a notice issued by Delhi Medical Council which made it mandatory for Doctors to register with the Council if they wanted to practice in the State of Delhi. The Doctors argued that it was an onerous requirement which would require them to register in every State they practice in. However, the Court held that the intent of the law is to require Doctors to register in every State that they practice in, and that Doctors have the option to register with multiple State Medical Councils in India.
Source: bit.ly/3TgHANw

Cosmetic Importers asked to provide sales details in a bid to curb import of counterfeit cosmetics
In an effort to curb the import of counterfeit cosmetic products, India’s Central Cosmetics Regulator, Drugs Controller General of India, has directed importers of cosmetics who import cosmetics already registered by authorized importers, to furnish annual sales details such as number of consignments, imported quantity, total cost of imported cosmetics of each consignment, along with warehouse details.
Source: bit.ly/42T2IMR

Central Government has to fix ceiling prices of medical treatment within 2 months: Supreme Court
The Supreme Court has directed the Central Government publish ceiling prices for medical treatments offered by Hospitals all over the country within 2 months. If the Central Government fails to do so, the Supreme Court has said that it will direct Central Government to fix medical treatment costs stipulated under Central Government Health Scheme as ceiling price of medical treatment offered by Hospitals for the whole country.
Source: bit.ly/3wsyHHs

India Seeks to delay implementation of EU Carbon Emissions Limits
India is set to conduct negotiation with the European Union regarding the implementation of the Carbon Control Regime, seeking a complete elimination of the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, failing which India will seek an extension of timelines for reduction of emissions. It is expected that in order to comply with requirements under EU Carbon Control Regime, Indian exporters will have to make significant capital investment will increase cost of production.
Source: bit.ly/42S7DxH

Posted on

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, We are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

Guidelines to differentiate brand extension from surrogate advertising issued
In a meeting with stakeholders, the Department of Consumer Affairs (DoCA) has clarified the difference between brand extension advertisements which are permitted, and surrogate advertisements which are not permitted. A brand extension advertisement should not contain direct or indirect references to prohibited products. It should also not use colour, layout, or presentations associated with the prohibited products.
Source: bit.ly/42PKVGk

Draft Pharmacovigilance Guidance Document published for comments
A draft of the revised Pharmacovigilance Guidance Document for Marketing Authorization Holders (MAHs) of Pharmaceutical Products has been published for comments. The last date for providing comments is March 23, 2024. This guidance document facilitates MAHs to setup & implementation of uniform Pharmacovigilance System for pharmaceutical products in the Indian market in the post-licensure period.
Source: bit.ly/3SSrfgw

Many small and medium pharmaceutical manufacturing units have been ordered shut down after increased surveillance
India’s central drug regulator, Central Drugs and Standards Control Organization (CDSCO), and state-level drug licensing authorities have reportedly issued show-cause notices to several drug small and medium manufacturers in the State of Punjab and Himachal Pradesh on grounds of poor quality control, and have also directed some of them to stop manufacturing.
Source: bit.ly/3I88UqP

Pharma MNCs exit domestic market due to regulatory headwinds
Many multinational pharmaceutical companies are reportedly cutting back on operations and manufacturing in India as part of a global strategic review due to regulatory headwinds on account of price control, rising costs, competition, and unfavourable intellectual property climate.
Source: bit.ly/42PaWW9

Frozen embryos should be treated as children: US Court
The Alabama State Supreme Court has ruled that frozen embryos in test tubes should be treated as ‘children’. This ruling has forced in vitro fertilization (IVF) providers in Alabama to stop treating patients, raising questions about the procedure’s continued availability in the state.
Source: bit.ly/3I8T4vR