TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Readers, we are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

1. In a new Amendment to the Food Safety and Standards (Prohibition and Restrictions on Sales) Regulations, 2011, the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) has clarified that BIS standards mark requirement may no longer be necessarily applicable for manufacture and sale of infant milk food, infant formula and milk cereal based weaning food etc. as well as Condensed milk sweetened, condensed skimmed milk sweetened, milk powder, skimmed milk powder, partly skimmed milk powder and partly skimmed sweetened.
Source: bit.ly/4hkwSPN
Source: bit.ly/3BXUuK4

2. In a recent amendment to the  Food Safety and Standards (Contaminants, toxins and Residues) First Regulations, 2011, which shall come into force from 1st April 2025 the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI)has: (1) Simplified and reduced the number of prohibited use Antimicrobials including chloroform, stilbenes and other steroids, (2) Increased the permissible concentration for Antimicrobials in Honey, (3) reduced the concentration of antimicrobials in cattle.
Source: bit.ly/3AdyXMN

3. The Rajasthan Authority for Advance Rulings held that the vanilla mix being sold by a major manufacturer of consumer food products in the country would not be classified as an “ice-cream” for the purpose of taxation under the Goods and Services Act, 2017 (GST Act) due to sugar being the major ingredient at about 65%. This decision in contrast to the Supreme Court’s decision on similar grounds.
Source: bit.ly/3BW78sY
Source: bit.ly/3BQh9I0

4. The Supreme Court quashed a criminal case which had been filed against a major Indian bank for non-compliance with an order of the authority under the Income Tax Act, holding that an allegation of mens rea cannot be made against a juristic person such as the bank and that the intention of the officers and functionaries cannot be construed to be that of the juristic person itself.
Source: bit.ly/3C5fH4y

5. The Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA), Australia’s regulator for Medical Devices has clarified some queries concerning its updated Essential Principles, which are necessary compliances for getting approval for devices in Australia. In this new update to the checklist, the TGA has reiterated its existing commitment to recognizing foreign approval standards, and has placed obligation on Sponsors to update the TGA if their Manufacturer Evidence may be expiring in 50 days, among other things.
Source: bit.ly/48jlWxM
Source: bit.ly/4eSYR7P

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear  Readers, we are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

1. India’s central drug regulator (CDSCO) has identified 59 drug samples as Not of Standard Quality (NSQ) in August, including products from major pharmaceutical manufacturers. The action has come after several states and union territories failed to report NSQ data, prompting the CDSCO to emphasize the need for timely submissions to enhance drug safety oversight.
Source: bit.ly/4drUUFz
Source: bit.ly/3zCDmJ0

2. The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission-II in Visakhapatnam has awarded a compensation of Rs. 15 lakhs in a medical negligence case and has found the private eye institute, its director, and two ophthalmologists guilty as they failed to meet their medical obligations by neglecting the crucial pre-surgery test of the patient leading to a loss of eyesight of the patient.
Source: bit.ly/3N6HST2

3. The Punjab and Haryana High Court has ordered the attachment of the salaries of several health officials, including the state health secretary for a potential diversion and unauthorised use of funds. The court held that the state cannot withhold the amount released by the central government due to hospitals under the Ayushman Bharat scheme and has asked for a detailed explanation from the state in the matter.
Source: bit.ly/3zCDt7o

4. India’s health ministry has issued draft regulations amending the Food Safety and Standards (Contaminants, Toxins and Residues) Regulations, 2011 to limit the Maximum Residue Limits (MRL) of pesticides/insecticides in each food community. The notification invites objections and suggestions from stakeholders regarding the proposed changes till November 17, 2024.
Source: bit.ly/47MlQOV

5. The Indian government has released a notification to include Acupuncture under the category “Other Care Professionals” in the schedule of the National Commission for Allied and Healthcare Professions Act, 2021.
Source: bit.ly/3ZJqXNO

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Readers, we are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

1. Due to a recent spike in cases, the Karnataka Government has declared dengue as an “epidemic” and to that effect has issued a notification under the Karnataka Epidemic Diseases Regulations, 2020. As part of the notification, the government has empowered Municipal Corporations across the state to carry out inspections of sites for compliance with mosquito prevention measures.
Source: bit.ly/3ThmkGK

2. Industry associations of manufacturers of Drugs and Medical Devices have called for an amendment of the Drugs (Prices Control) Order, 2013 to make pricing guidelines uniform for both Scheduled and non-scheduled formulations.
Source: bit.ly/3AJuTUn

3. India’s Central food regulator, the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India has issued a notification to re-operationalize The Food Safety Standards (Health Supplements, Nutraceuticals, Food for Special Dietary Use, Food for Special Medical Purpose and Prebiotic and Probiotic Food) Regulations, 2022, in the interim of formulating new regulations.
Source: bit.ly/3ASeVYj

4. It is reported that IT’s upcoming meeting scheduled for 9th September, the Goods and Services Tax Council may take a decision on removing the existing 18% Goods and Services Tax on health insurance policies.
Source: bit.ly/3TjjrWa

5. In pursuance of its larger and long-term project of fighting and reducing anti-microbial resistance, the World Health Organization has issued a guidance directing management of “antibiotic waste” generated by manufacturers, which contributes to rising levels of anti-microbial resistance.
Source: bit.ly/4g922t1

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Readers, we are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

1. Use of artificial yellow food coloring ‘Tartrazine’ in food items like moong dal is not food adulteration as ‘Tartrazine’ is a permitted food coloring under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Rules, 1955; India’s Supreme Court.
Source: bit.ly/4718Tk4

2. Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) has withdrawn the clarification for selling / marketing of milk and milk products in the name of A1 & A2 for further consultation. Previously, FSSAI had clarified that it is misleading to differentiate milk and milk products on whether they are made from A1 milk or A2 milk and had thereby directed to remove such claims from such products including e-commerce websites.
Source: bit.ly/4778axU

3. Retail prices to be reportedly reduced by 50% of anti-diabetic drug Empagliflozin, which is expected to go off patent in March 2025 under Drugs Price Control Order, 2013.
Source: bit.ly/470IFxW

4. Indian Pharmaceutical Industry has urged to amend and delete the term “retailer” from the definition of dealer under Drugs Price Control Order, 2013 (DPCO). Manufacturers and importers are required to furnish price list to dealers. The inclusion of ‘retailer’ within the definition of ‘dealer’ has led to confusion over the extent of this obligation, potentially extending the manufacturer’s and importer’s liability beyond wholesalers to include retailers as well. If approved, Retailers, who typically interact with consumers directly, would be excluded from the manufacturer’s direct regulatory responsibilities, thereby allowing the focus to remain on the wholesale distribution channel.
Source: bit.ly/3ABX4Vs

5. QR Codes / Bar Codes may reportedly be made mandatory for vaccines, cancer drugs and antibiotics to validate the authenticity of drugs and prevent the supply of counterfeits.
Source: bit.ly/475pDGH

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Readers, we are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

1. India’s central food regulator, Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) has said that it is misleading to differentiate milk and milk products on whether they are made from A1 milk or A2 milk. All manufacturers and marketers and e-commerce entities have been directed to stop claims of A1 and A2 proteins present in the milk. All manufacturers have been given six months to exhaust all of the pre-printed labels containing claims about A1 and A2 proteins.
Source: bit.ly/4dz5awA

2. The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) has released updated guidelines for assessing environmental compensation to be levied on entities that violate the Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016, including Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) obligations.
Source: bit.ly/46Uh9lX

3. India’s Ministry of Health has banned the 156 fixed-dose combination (FDC) medications, commonly known as “cocktail drugs,” which include multivitamins, antibiotics, and painkillers. The ministry’s rationale is that these drugs have no there is no therapeutic justification and pose a risk to human health, even though there are safer alternatives available.
Source: bit.ly/3XfRVeq

4. The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has issued a draft guidance on pre-determined change control plans (PCCPs). The guidelines offer manufacturers a way to specify prospective modifications to a device and apply for premarket authorization for those changes in a marketing submission for the device. This eliminates the need for them to obtain FDA approval for each major change before it is implemented. The draft guidance is open to receiving comments from industry stakeholders till November 20, 2024.
Source: bit.ly/3AtTY5B

5. The Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), an agency of the Department of Health and Social Care in the United Kingdom, has ruled that a biopharmaceutical company has violated the country’s drug regulations by using a LinkedIn post to advertise prescription-only medicines to the general public.
Source: bit.ly/4fSmKgt

Can cooking oil be lawfully reused in India? An analysis of law and recent KFC case

Under Indian law, it is not unlawful to reuse cooking oil, provided certain conditions and thresholds are not crossed by food businesses. In this article, we will examine the thresholds and conditions associated with reusing cooking oil. We will also examine the Madras High Court order which protected a fast-food chain outlet against arbitrary action of suspension of license for reusing cooking oil.

Thresholds and Conditions for Reuse of Cooking Oil

The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) is the regulatory body responsible for quality of food for consumers. It regulates the use and reuse of cooking oil and issues directions from time to time.

The FSSAI has recommended that “re-heating and reuse of oil should be avoided as far as possible”. It has further recommended that cooking oil should be reheated a maximum of three times, and that ideally it should be heated only once. However, these recommendations are for guidance only are not binding on food businesses.

The only legal restriction on reusing vegetable cooking oil is that the Total Polar Compounds (TPC) developed in cooking oil due to reheating cannot exceed 25%[1]. According to FSSAI, any cooking oil whose TPC content is more than 25% is unsafe for human consumption and is thereby prohibited for use.

In order to keep a check on TPC content in reused vegetable cooking oil, FSSAI has directed that food businesses using 50 litres or more of cooking oil per day to maintain records detailing oil usage, including type, quantity used and discarded, and disposal date. Such food businesses are required to dispose the used cooking oil (UCO) only to FSSAI-approved aggregators or collection agencies.[2]

Adding fresh cooking oil to used cooking oil

In 2019, FSSAI directed food businesses to ensure that used cooking oil should not be topped with fresh cooking oil.[3]

Legal consequences of reusing cooking oil

Any violation of the 25% TPC threshold limit may result in suspension or cancellation of food license[4], as well as imprisonment or fine.[5]

Madras High Court’s intervention in unlawful suspension of license for reusing cooking oil

In Thoothukudi, Tamil Nadu, the FSSAI through Tamil Nadu Food Safety and Drug Administration Department (“Department”) suspended (i.e. temporarily cancelled) the license of one Kentucky Fried Chicken (“KFC”) outlet on grounds that it was reusing cooking oil and was adding a filtration agent, namely Magnesium Silicate Synthetic (“MSS”), to the cooking oil.

KFC challenged the suspension before the Madras High Court. On review, the High Court found that prima facie Magnesium Silicate Synthetic (MSS) does not appear to be a banned substance. On the contrary, it is an approved filtration agent. The Court further observed that there is no legal bar on reusing cooking oil.

For these reasons, and also on account of the fact that the Department did not follow due process before suspending the license, the Court passed an interim order staying the suspension of license and allowed the KFC outlet to resume operations.

Can Magnesium Silicate Synthetic (MSS) be added to reused cooking oil?

Magnesium Silicate Synthetic is a food additive that is primarily used as an anticaking agent and as a carrier for flavours in different food items. The Food Safety and Standards (Food Products Standards and Food Additives) Regulation, 2011 limits the use of anti-caking agents in such cases where its use is specifically permitted.[6] Synthetic Magnesium Silicate (or Magnesium Silicate Synthetic) is recognized an additive that may be used as clarifying agents or filtration aid in edible oils[7] and therefore may be lawfully used as a filtration aid in cooking oil.

Conclusion

The controversy surrounding reuse of cooking oil by restaurants seem to be manufactured, since the law surrounding reuse of cooking oil is very clear – vegetable cooking oils may be reheated and reused so long as the TPC content in the cooking oil does not exceed 25%. It is, however, recommended that cooking oil should not be reheated more than three times, though following such recommendation is not a legal requirement.

 

[1] The Food Safety and Standards (Licensing and Registration of Food Businesses) First Amendment Regulations, 2017, available at: https://www.fssai.gov.in/upload/uploadfiles/files/Gazette_Notification_Quality_Vegetable_Oil_03_11_2017.pdf  and Section 2.3.15(8) of FSS (Prohibition and Restriction on Sales) Regulations, 2011, available at: 61f381c576d16SOP_Cooking_Oil_28_01_2022.pdf (fssai.gov.in)

[2] Direction under Section 16(5) of the FSS Act regarding disposal and collection of Used Cooking Oil, available at:  5c6271f25d447Direction_Reused_Cooking_Oil_07_02_2019.pdf (fssai.gov.in)

[3] Direction under Section 16(5) of the FSS Act regarding disposal and collection of Used Cooking Oil, available at: 5c6271f25d447Direction_Reused_Cooking_Oil_07_02_2019.pdf (fssai.gov.in)

[4] Regulation 2.1.8 (4) of the Food Safety and Standards(Licensing and Registration of Food Businesses) Regulations, 2011, available at: https://www.fssai.gov.in/upload/uploadfiles/files/Licensing_Regulations.pdf

[5] Section 55, 57 and 59 of the Food Safety and Security Act, 2006 (“Act”), and Section 274, 275 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.

[6] 3.1.7: Anticaking Agents: 1) Restriction on use of anticaking agents. No anticaking agents shall be used in any food except where the use of anticaking agents is specifically permitted. [Page 430, Part III, Section 4, the Food Safety and Standards (Licensing and Registration of Food Businesses) Regulations of 2011].

[7]Direction under Section 16(5) of the FSS Act regarding compliance w.r.t. Processing Aids under Food Safety and Standards (Licensing and Registration of Food Businesses) Regulations of 2011, available at:  https://fssai.gov.in/upload/advisories/2024/03/65f2d680c053cApproved%20direction%20under%20Section%2016_5%20regarding%20compliance%20w.r.t.%20Processing%20Aids%20under%20FSS_FPS&FA_Regulations_2011.pdf

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

Dear Reader, we are happy to share the most interesting legal and policy updates concerning health industry that we read today. We hope you enjoy reading it.

1. In its recent annual Budget announcement, the central government has proposed to waive customs tariffs on three additional drugs, used in treatment of cancer.
Source: bit.ly/4dinoSC

2. The Bombay High Court held a Director of a chemical manufacturer criminally liable for export of controlled substances from the country, holding that all officers of companies should keep themselves abreast of the latest regulations, and being ignorant of new notified compliance cannot excuse liability.
Source: bit.ly/46iRp22

3. The Madras High Court stayed a suspension order issued against a branch of a major fast food chain, holding that suspension cannot be ordered without giving an opportunity to improve its practices in pursuance of an Improvement Notice issued under Sec. 32(1) of the Food Safety Standards Act, 2006.
Source: bit.ly/3LFGne4

4. The Ethics and Medical Registration Board of the National Medical Commission of India, the country’s premier regulator of the medical profession has recently issued a decision proposing to expand the scope of qualified Doctors that may now be permitted to undertake spinal surgery. While previously only neurology specialists were permitted to operate on the spine, orthopedic specialists may also undertake the same with existing qualifications.
Source: bit.ly/46s1oCn

5. An appeals courts of the United States has rejected the petition of several US states against the reclassification of contraceptive medication, holding that no grounds were established to prove actual harm suffered by the State governments. as claimed.
Source: bit.ly/3zZpdFC

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

1. India’s Central Food Regulator the Food Safety Standards Authority, has introduced registration process for direct sellers to differentiate from Retailers, and make it easier to preserve exemption granted from regulation to direct sellers.

Source: bit.ly/4feuedl

 

2. The Kerala High Court in following with a recent decision of the Punjab High Court has held that the newly enforced Criminal Procedure (The Bharatiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2024) will apply to all criminal appeals filed on or after 1st July 2024, the day of enforcement of the  new law. The court held that while the substantial right to appeal is preserved under the repealed statute, the procedural right will transfer over as per Sec. 531 of the new Code.

Source: bit.ly/4bQpMi4

 

3. Exports of Drugs and Pharmaceuticals have reportedly increased by 9.5% in the first quarter of FY 2024-25 year-on-year.

Source: bit.ly/4d3x3Nb

 

4. In response to recent reports that India has the 2nd highest number of unvaccinated children, the Indian government has clarified in a press release that, this statistic is misleading as such children only constitute a minute 0.11% of the nation’s population of children.

Source: bit.ly/3zQzFPw

 

5. The United States Food and Drug Administration has published Guidance for Human radiolabeled mass balanced studies, prescribing the information that sponsors need to submit, most notably now requiring a minimum of 6 participants for such studies as against the accepted variance between 4-6 participants.

Source: bit.ly/3y2UEy8

Medical Fitness Certificate for Food Handlers: How to ensure compliance with this Mandatory License Condition?

All Food Business Operators (FBOs) in India must maintain a record of annual medical examination of all food handler(s) engaged by the FBO. This is a mandatory condition of the food license. The Food Safety Officer checks the record of medical examination at the time of inspection, and any shortcoming in the record-keeping may result in suspension or cancellation of license.

In this article, we will discuss key considerations for ensuring full compliance with the requirement of maintaining records of medical examinations of food handlers.

Who is a food handler?

A food handler is any person who directly handles packaged or unpackaged food, food equipment, utensils, or food contact surfaces, and is therefore expected to comply with food hygiene requirements.

Personal hygiene and sanitary requirements applicable to FBOs

In addition to the requirement of a medical examination of food handlers, all FBOs have to ensure that no person, whether handling food or not, who may be suffering from any disease or illness that is likely to be transmitted through food is allowed to enter any area where the food is handled, i.e., where the food is packaged or unpackaged, where food equipment and utensils are stored, where food contact surfaces exist, or where food is cooked or manufactured.

In addition to the above general requirement, FBOs who are involved in high-risk food businesses such as meat and dairy have additional personal hygiene and cleanliness requirements, which are discussed below.

Meat

FBOs who deal in meat must ensure that any person who comes into contact with meat in the course of his or her work must be medically examined prior to such person being engaged. FBOs who run meat shops must ensure that any person who handles meat is medically examined annually, and the medical examination includes an examination of the sputum and chest X-ray for tuberculosis. The medical examination should also include stool tests for parasitic infections (protozoal and helminthic) transmitted through ingestion, as well as for enteropathogenic bacteria such as Escherichia coli, Salmonella, Shigella species, and Vibrio cholera.

Dairy

FBOs who manufacture, process, store, or sell milk and milk products are required to ensure that the persons employed for handling raw materials or dairy products have, before joining, submitted a medical certificate that states that there is no medical impediment to working in the specific capacity or role that the person is going to be employed by the FBO.

Mandatory vaccination of workers working in food factory    

If the FBO is a manufacturer, processor, and packer who operates a factory, then all workers working in the factory ought to be compulsorily vaccinated against an enteric group of diseases as per the recommended schedule of vaccination. Enteric groups of disease are infections caused by viruses and bacteria that enter the body through the mouth or intestinal system, primarily as a result of eating, drinking, and digesting contaminated food or liquids. Cholera, typhoid fever, Salmonella, or E. coli are some common enteric diseases. A record of the vaccination of all factory workers is required to be maintained, which may be inspected at the time of inspection. The decision regarding the scope of vaccination, i.e., which enteric diseases are to be covered by vaccination, is taken by the registered medical practitioner according to the list declared by the concerned municipal corporation of the area.

Format of Medical Fitness Certificate 

After the medical examination of food handlers, a medical fitness certificate in the prescribed format must be issued by a registered medical practitioner. It must contain the signature and seal of the registered medical practitioner. The medical fitness certificate should indicate that the registered medical practitioner has undertaken a physical examination, an eye test, and a skin examination, as well as any other tests required to confirm any communicable or infectious disease that the person is suspected to be suffering as observed during the clinical examination, if applicable. It should also indicate that “based on the medical examination, he/she is found free from any infectious or communicable diseases, and the person is fit to work in the food establishment.”

Discretionary Powers of Food Safety Officer vis-à-vis ordering medical examination of workers

If a Food Safety Officer, during an inspection, believes that the food handler is suffering from any infectious disease, he may ask for a medical examination of that person, and on such examination, if he finds out that person is suffering from an infectious disease, he has the authority to prohibit employees suffering from infectious diseases from participating in food handling activities and ensure strict adherence to health and safety.

Penalty for non-compliance

Failure to comply with these regulations can result in penalties of up to two lakh rupees and potential license cancellation under Section 58 of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006.

Conclusion 

All FBOs should sensitize themselves to the legal requirements of annual medical examination of staff, mandatory vaccination of workers working in food factories, and general hygiene and sanitary requirements applicable to all persons handling food or operating in an area where food is handled. Failure to meet these requirements of food laws may result in a heavy monetary fine and suspension or cancellation of the license.

TOP 5 HEALTH LAWS AND POLICY UPDATES

1. The Central Government is mulling including non-prescription Neutraceuticals currently regulated by the Central government food regulator the Food Safety Standards Authority of India, under the price control regime similar to Drug price regulation under the Drugs (Prices control) Order, 2013.
Source: bit.ly/4cRZVb7

2. The Supreme Court in continuation of prior orders issued acknowledging the concerns raised in a petition seeking to address the shortage of life saving Antiretroviral Drugs in the country, has granted the request of the petitioner to discuss the access of quality Antiretroviral Drugs to persons dealing with HIV.
Source: bit.ly/4cAATg9

3. The Central Government has issued a Draft Notification proposing amendment to the Drugs Rules, 1945, mainly intending to introduce restriction on advertising Drugs listed in Schedule G of the Rules.
Source: bit.ly/3Whm0Ke
Source: bit.ly/3VZZ0Or

4. Then United States Federal Trade Commission is set to take action against Drug supply middlemen and major pharmacy chains for use of anticompetitive tactics in negotiating Drug prices.
Source: bit.ly/3WgtAom

5. The World Health Organization has issued a new and updated list of pathogens, to reorient the prioritization in combating Antimicrobial Resistance.
Source: bit.ly/4czZdiw